SUTTONS BAY — The Inland Seas Education Association’s (ISEA) plan to renovate and expand the historic Millside building has been delayed, but both the organization and Suttons Bay officials say the project is still moving forward with strong cooperation.
The Suttons Bay Planning Commission decided not to approve ISEA’s site plan at its most recent meeting, citing the need to clarify zoning details — particularly how to classify Dame Street, a narrow access road that affects the layout of the project.
Planning officials emphasized that the pause does not reflect opposition to the project.
“We’re excited about the project,” said Planning Commission Manager Rob Llera. “There are a few things to work through, but it’s a natural progression.”
ISEA leaders say they appreciate the village’s approach. The nonprofit has already raised more than $10 million toward the renovation, which would expand classroom space, improve maintenance areas for the schoolship fleet, and revitalize a downtown building.
“The village is trying to follow their zoning ordinances while also helping an important project move forward,” said Executive Director Fred Sitkins. “We feel like we’re in a good place.”
The Planning Commission is expected to revisit the site plan at its December 17 meeting. If approved, ISEA plans to bid the project in spring 2026 and begin construction shortly after.
Village officials say the temporary delay is part of the normal review process for adaptive reuse projects, which do not always fit neatly within current zoning standards. Both sides say they expect to resolve the remaining questions before the end of the year.